Canada’s immigration minister is getting pushback from companies that heavily rely on foreign labour following the federal government’s announcement that it will cap international student visas. Marc Miller said companies, including “big-box stores,” are already lobbying against the planned reduction in permitted work hours for international students in comments made Tuesday to BNN Bloomberg.
“Some of the big-box stores, some of the businesses that have international students, have pushed relatively hard to preserve the 40-hour work week,” Miller said. “Some student groups call for it as well because a lot of employers want you to be able to commit to more than 20 hours.”
The Retail Council of Canada — which represents 45,000 store fronts across the country, including Canada’s largest grocers, Walmart and Amazon Canada — in an email said that “the labour shortage is real, and finding people has never been more difficult.” Many of the big box stores the RCC represents employ international students, said spokesperson Michelle Wasylyshen.
Miller’s comments follow the government’s announcement last month that it will restrict access to work permits for foreign students and their spouses as part of new measures meant to limit and curb the abuse of Canada’s international education program.
‘Addicted to temporary foreign workers’
It also confirmed that Canada will implement a two-year cap on international study permits with an aim of reducing the number issued by 35 per cent from 2023’s level, to 364,000 in 2024.
Miller told BNN Bloomberg that he will announce further changes soon to restrict students’ off-campus work hours and said he’s also reviewing the country’s temporary foreign worker (TFW) program which has been undergoing a massive expansion over the last year and allows employers to hire migrant workers on time-limited visas to fill temporary jobs to address labour shortages.
“We have gotten addicted to temporary foreign workers,” Miller said. But experts and advocates say Miller’s comments highlight contradictions in the government’s recent immigration policy changes.
Despite criticism that record immigration numbers are contributing to unaffordable housing, Miller’s comments show that the Canadian economy and businesses continue to rely on foreign workers and international students for cheap labour and to fill labour gaps, said Sheila Block, a senior economist and research associate with the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives.
A ‘highly exploitable’ workforce
Employers have grown accustomed to the ceaseless supply of international students to fill low-wage jobs in fast-food restaurants, retail, warehouses, factories and gig work.
“This is a workforce that is highly exploitable,” Block said, adding that the surge of cheap labour disincentivizes companies from raising wages and improving conditions that are likely leading to labour shortages in the first place. Companies need to “increase wages to attract more workers,” Block said. “If you have an increase in wages at the bottom, then that’s going to push up wages in the middle as well.”
According to a recent RBC report, newcomers earn less than the general population and are also more likely to have inadequate housing. The government and business are “coming up against their own contradictions,” said Deena Ladd, executive director of the Workers’ Action Centre. “They desperately need (workers),” Ladd said, “to do the jobs that nobody else wants to do.”
It’s “a situation that’s ripe for abuse,” she added, saying foreign workers often have precarious immigration status or are tied to one employer as a condition of their work permit — which means that complaining about an employer could cost a worker their job and legal status in Canada.
Miller said that Canada is prepared to take on the economic impact of limiting temporary migration and that he’s concerned about the abuse of workers in low-wage sectors, but BNN Bloomberg said he declined to elaborate.
“The question we posed to ourselves is: do we want that short-term gain for a lot of long-term pain?” he told BNN Bloomberg. The Retail Council of Canada wants a permanent regulation allowing 30 hours of work a week when classes are in session, BNN Bloomberg reported.
“For international students, retail can provide a way to supplement their incomes, enhance language skills, and provide useful employment skills — everything from front-line retail and customer service, to logistics and supply chain,” Wasylyshen told the Star in an email.
But Block said limiting international student visas is not the solution and that foreign workers are being scapegoated. “We have to make sure that those who arrive here have all the protections that Canadian workers have,” Block said.
