June 21, 2024
It seems Canada’s largest bank isn’t expecting a whole lot of upside in the short-term from what appears to be the start of a campaign by the Bank of Canada to bring interest rates down.
Interest rate cuts won’t provide an immediate boost to Canada’s lagging economy or the debt payment relief some households are seeking, a new analysis from Royal Bank of Canada suggests.
Despite signs around the world that economies are starting to rally, including in the euro area and the United Kingdom, Canada’s economy has continued to struggle on a GDP-per-capita basis with the metric running three per cent below levels seen in 2019. Craig Wright, senior vice-president and chief economist at Royal Bank of Canada, notes that is a 10 per cent swing relative to the U.S., where per capita GDP is up seven per cent in that timeframe.
“The global economic growth backdrop has shown signs of improvement, but Canada’s economy continues to underperform,” Wright said in a report published on Wednesday. “The Bank of Canada’s pivot to cut interest rates in June is more akin to easing off the monetary policy brakes than stepping on the gas.”
Indebted households will obviously cheer rate cuts, but “the lagged impact of past interest rate increases will continue to push debt payments higher,” Wright said, estimating that moves by the central bank likely won’t lead to an uptick in growth until sometime next year. For 2024, RBC predicts real GDP will come in at one per cent rising to 1.8 per cent in 2025.
For the first time in four years, the Bank of Canada cut its benchmark lending rate by 25 basis points to 4.75 per cent on June 6, citing, among its reason for doing so, a weakening economy, excess supply and slowing inflation.
“We assume another 75 basis points of BoC cuts this year, but that will still leave the level of interest rates above those neutral levels and subtract on net from economic growth, just by less than currently,” Wright said.
The reason for that is the expected cuts would still leave the bank’s rate well above the 2.25 per cent to 3.25 per cent range that the Bank of Canada considers neutral, meaning it neither stimulates nor suppresses economic growth.
Looking at the mortgage landscape, Royal Bank’s chief economist estimates there are approximately $200 billion worth of mortgages, most with four- and five-year terms, that will be renegotiated this year with $275 billion up for renewal in 2025.
Households will feel the impact of higher rates, but Wright said the jump in payments appears “manageable” against the increases in incomes that have risen dramatically from pre-pandemic levels.
“The expected payment shock this year will still be large for individual households impacted, but accounts for a relatively small 0.2 per cent of total Canadian household incomes, according to our estimates,” Wright said.
However, the bank’s chief economist doesn’t foresee rate cuts helping with housing affordability due to a “structural” shortage of accomodation, nor does he see lower rates helping with declining productivity.
RBC also produced GDP forecasts for the provinces.
Ontario, Quebec and British Columbia are expected to grow the slowest — 0.5 per cent, 0.7 per cent and 0.8 per cent, respectively — of the provinces given that they are home to many of Canada’s most indebted households.
GDP in the Prairie provinces is expected to expand more than the country as a whole with Alberta’s economy growing 1.7 per cent as “households and businesses — which took past interest rate hikes in stride — have already amped up spending activity in anticipation of rate cuts,” Wright said.
“A slight pickup in oil prices should help as well.”
